(#2006-2468) - Topics this issue: 1) Some questions, 2) Only six new songs, 3) Only six new songs, 4) Some questions, 5) Some questions, 6) Some questions, 7) Some questions, ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Date: Sun, 24 Sep 2006 00:17:41 +0900 From: "Robert S. Kim" Subject: Some questions No answers were given to my previous question about 'They Keep on Singing', but I found it to be 'Live by Request' and 'Top of The Pops 2001'. Can you tell me how the following songs are related to the Bee Gees? 1. Lost & Found - 20 She's Like The Devil.mp3 (URL: http://68.109.231.118/pub/questions/01.mp3) This is a Beatles' song 'She's Got The Devil in Her Heart'. Did the Bee Gees sing this one actually? 2. Lost & Found - 10 Kangoory Dance.mp3 (URL: http://68.109.231.118/pub/questions/02.mp3) Did the Bee Gees sing 'Tie Me Kangaroo Down Sport', too? I don't this is the Bee Gees' voice. 3. Lost & Found - 17 Morning Sun.mp3 (URL: http://68.109.231.118/pub/questions/03.mp3) I guess this is Maurice's voice. 4. Lost & Found - 28 Woman.mp3 (URL: http://68.109.231.118/pub/questions/04.mp3) 5. Please Welcome - 02 Still Waters (The View 97 - Live).mp3 (URL: http://68.109.231.118/pub/questions/05.mp3) I want to know what shows featured the above song of the Bee Gees, with the exact air date. 6. An Irrestible Force - 01 World Beat On CNN.mp3 (URL: http://68.109.231.118/pub/questions/06.mp3) 7. An Irrestible Force - 02 Stayin' Alive[Fashion Show Mix][1996].mp3 (URL: http://68.109.231.118/pub/questions/07.mp3) Plus, Can you tell me where the following songs were performed or how they were related to the Bee Gees? 8. Improvisatation on Piano (from Loner) 9. Medley (Jive Talkin'+Stayin' Alive) (from Instrumental and Other Rarities) 10. Medley (Stayin' Alive+More Than A Woman+Jive Talkin' +Tragedy+You Should Be Dancin') (from Instrumental and Other Rarities) 11. One (Soundcheck - Live) (from One Demos) 12. Square Cup (Max Greger Orchestra) (from Instrumental and Other Rarities) 13. This Time (from Instrumental and Other Rarities) Thanks in advance for your answer. Robert ------------------------------ Date: Sat, 23 Sep 2006 12:17:38 EDT From: Compoccias@aol.com Subject: Re: Only six new songs In a message dated 9/22/2006 5:03:16 PM Eastern Standard Time, brennan@columbia.edu writes: Did you notice one that's not on my web pages? In the list of tape reels that I used, one reel was noted as "completely unoriginal", so I ignored it. That turns out to be a song title! Joe Brennan I wondered what that track was also. So, its an actual song or an instrumental perhaps? I also noticed that "Mrs. Gillespie's Refrigerator" and "Deeply Deeply Me" are included in the Horizontal accompanying CD as opposed to the Bee gees 1st extra disc. Shouldn't those two songs be included on the latter, given the timeline presented in your guide? Sal ------------------------------ Date: Sat, 23 Sep 2006 12:55:47 -0400 From: Joseph Brennan Subject: Re: Only six new songs --On Saturday, September 23, 2006 12:17 PM -0400 Compoccias@aol.com wrote: > I also noticed that "Mrs. Gillespie's Refrigerator" and "Deeply Deeply > Me" are included in the Horizontal accompanying CD as opposed to the > Bee gees 1st extra disc. Shouldn't those two songs be included on the > latter, given the timeline presented in your guide? Some of the source material is not dated. They started on songs for Horizontal immediately after completing First, so it's a pretty close call for something that might be middle of 1967. My gut feeling is earlier rather than later. Joe ------------------------------ Date: Sat, 23 Sep 2006 13:17:33 -0400 From: Joseph Brennan Subject: Re: Some questions > 3. Lost & Found - 17 Morning Sun.mp3 > (URL: http://68.109.231.118/pub/questions/03.mp3) > I guess this is Maurice's voice. It doesn't sound to me like any of them. Some bootlegger included it on a Maurice collection. > 4. Lost & Found - 28 Woman.mp3 > (URL: http://68.109.231.118/pub/questions/04.mp3) Written by Paul McCartney under a pseudonym, and performed by Peter and Gordon, 1966. The announcer is saying this in the intro! > 5. Please Welcome - 02 Still Waters (The View 97 - Live).mp3 > (URL: http://68.109.231.118/pub/questions/05.mp3) > I want to know what shows featured the above song of the > Bee Gees, with the exact air date. There is an ABC (US) talk show "The View" that started Aug 11, 1997. I don't recall the Bee Gees being on it, but I forget things. The song was released as a single in the US in November. > 8. Improvisatation on Piano (from Loner) This name is given to the end of "She's the One You Love". Some bootlegger broke it off to a separate track and then others copied that. It should not be separate. Notice Maurice saying "a little bit of ping pong" while playing. There is an unheard B & M song named "Ping Pong" from early 1969. > 12. Square Cup (Max Greger Orchestra) > (from Instrumental and Other Rarities) Single by "Orchester Max Greger" ("Max Greger Orchestra" in English), Polydor, Germany, 1969. Max Greger was a popular musician in Germany. Written by B R & M in 1968. > 13. This Time (from Instrumental and Other Rarities) By Maurice, recorded the same day as "Alabama", April 20, 1970. It sounds like a backing track for a song, not a proper instrumental. Joe Brennan ------------------------------ Date: Sun, 24 Sep 2006 02:39:32 +0900 From: "Robert S. Kim" Subject: Re: Some questions Thanks a million, Joe. On 24/09/06, Joseph Brennan wrote: > > > 3. Lost & Found - 17 Morning Sun.mp3 > > (URL: http://68.109.231.118/pub/questions/03.mp3) > > I guess this is Maurice's voice. > > It doesn't sound to me like any of them. Some bootlegger included it > on a Maurice collection. > > > > 4. Lost & Found - 28 Woman.mp3 > > (URL: http://68.109.231.118/pub/questions/04.mp3) > > Written by Paul McCartney under a pseudonym, and performed by Peter > and Gordon, 1966. The announcer is saying this in the intro! > > > > 5. Please Welcome - 02 Still Waters (The View 97 - Live).mp3 > > (URL: http://68.109.231.118/pub/questions/05.mp3) > > I want to know what shows featured the above song of the > > Bee Gees, with the exact air date. > > There is an ABC (US) talk show "The View" that started Aug 11, 1997. > I don't recall the Bee Gees being on it, but I forget things. The > song was released as a single in the US in November. > > > > 8. Improvisatation on Piano (from Loner) > > This name is given to the end of "She's the One You Love". Some > bootlegger broke it off to a separate track and then others copied > that. It should not be separate. > > Notice Maurice saying "a little bit of ping pong" while playing. > There is an unheard B & M song named "Ping Pong" from early 1969. > > > > 12. Square Cup (Max Greger Orchestra) > > (from Instrumental and Other Rarities) > > Single by "Orchester Max Greger" ("Max Greger Orchestra" in English), > Polydor, Germany, 1969. Max Greger was a popular musician in Germany. > Written by B R & M in 1968. > > > > 13. This Time (from Instrumental and Other Rarities) > > By Maurice, recorded the same day as "Alabama", April 20, 1970. It > sounds like a backing track for a song, not a proper instrumental. > > > > Joe Brennan > > > > > > > > "Words & Music", Fans Of The Brothers Gibb ( Bee Gees ) > http://www.brothersgibb.com > > To change any of your list options, > please go to website listed above. > > ------------------------------ Date: Sat, 23 Sep 2006 14:06:21 EDT From: Compoccias@aol.com Subject: Re: Some questions In a message dated 9/23/2006 1:20:00 PM Eastern Standard Time, brennan@columbia.edu writes: >There is an ABC (US) talk show "The View" that started Aug 11, 1997. >I don't recall the Bee Gees being on it, but I forget things. The >song was released as a single in the US in November. They were on "The View". My mother watches the show and she had told me that she saw them on the program back then . Sal ------------------------------ Date: Sat, 23 Sep 2006 19:50:58 +0100 From: =?iso-8859-1?Q?Andrew_M=F4n_Hughes?= Subject: Re: Some questions From: "Joseph Brennan" >> 3. Lost & Found - 17 Morning Sun.mp3 >> (URL: http://68.109.231.118/pub/questions/03.mp3) >> I guess this is Maurice's voice. > > It doesn't sound to me like any of them. Some bootlegger included it > on a Maurice collection. This was in a batch of acetates that a big collector bought as they were supposed to be Maurice related items. I think "Song For Lulu" was amongst them also. We've speculated that they could be Tin Tin, or Norman Hitchcock, but never come up with anything conclusive. >> 13. This Time (from Instrumental and Other Rarities) > > By Maurice, recorded the same day as "Alabama", April 20, 1970. It > sounds like a backing track for a song, not a proper instrumental. It has lyrics for sure - written by Billy Lawrie. Andrew ------------------------------ End words@brothersgibb.com Digest [09/23/2006 15:01] ----------------------------------------------------